MEMBER CIGAR REVIEWS | STAFF CIGAR REVIEWS | CIGAR VIDEOS | ONE ON ONE INTERVIEWS | CIGAR NEWS | CIGAR FORUMS | PIPES | LIFESTYLE | CONTACT
 
Excalibur by HDM No. I (M) Cigar Reviews
Below are the cigar reviews for the Excalibur by HDM No. I (M). If you would like to add your own personal cigar review for the Excalibur by HDM No. I (M) please click here.


Cigar Vitals


Excalibur by HDM Cigars
  No. I (M)       

Current Rating
8.63

Size: NA
Shape: Double Corona
Wrapper: NA
Filler: NA
Binder: NA
MSRP: 5.75
Total Reviews: 81
Average Rating: 8.63 out of a possible 10
Average Price: 5.32
Discontinued: No
Notes:

Quick Rating
100% of voters like the Excalibur by HDM - No. I (M)
Vote Now! This cigar SMOKES! (14) This cigar is a DUD. (0)

Page 2 of 17 :: PREVIOUS PAGE | NEXT PAGE

"A classic-- extremely underrated."

Review by: DW
Review Date: 01/18/2010
Rating: 9.2
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: I have smoked at least 20 of these cigars, and I have yet to have any construction issues or any uneven burn-- talk about consistency!! Unlike some of the reviewers who said that this cigar is not complex, I beg to differ. There is a clear progression and development of flavors-- creamy coffee-like notes to an earthiness that is pronounced but not offensive. There are underlying notes of spice and pepper that don't predominate, but are there. There is a "sweetness" that stays with you as you smoke it. It has a "finish" to it that reminds me of some of the great Padrons and Cubans that I have had. Everything is well blended-- a testament to the artistry of its crafter. They are good enough to smoke straight from the box-- no aging needed. More aging only makes them better. This cigar is so consistent, it's incredible. Every one tastes the same. Burns the same. Smokes the same. No variation. This was one of the first cigars that I tried when I started smoking. I came back to these years later after my palate evolved (hundreds of cigars, cubans included). This is a prime time, world class smoke, and I believe it can hold its own among many of the world's finest smokes. No, it's not the best one that I have had, but for the price (Only 4 bucks????-- should be at least 12 or so) and for what it has to offer, this is one of the best cigars on the market. Pure artistry.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (9) No (3)

"To the last reviewer Daniel..."

Review by: Drew
Review Date: 01/06/2010
Rating: 8.2
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: Daniel, you said it had holes in it. It was probably infested with cigar beetles which will ruin it. As I have a local JR Cigar nearby I can get these pretty cheap and they are good everyday cigars. Perfect for the course or just when you have a craving and you won't feel guilty if you don't finish.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (12) No (12)

"Worst smoke I have ever had"

Review by: Daniel
Review Date: 12/26/2009
Rating: 1
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: Thus cigar was so bad that I thre it out 1/4 way through. The cap was so small that I had no choice but to punch it. The wraper was full of holes and started to unwind. Taste was harsh and had a chemical flavor to it. Not sure if I got a complete dud or not but this cigar should have never left the factory in the condition that it was in. The fact that their quality control was so poor as to let this stick ever see the light of day makes me want to avoid all sticks by this brand.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (2) No (9)

"Among the very finest!!!"

Review by: buckeyemike57
Review Date: 09/30/2009
Rating: 9.2
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: A must have in your humidor!!! Excellent appearance, construction, and flavor. The wrapper is excellent with an outstanding label. I smoked the first of 5 that I bought 5 days after receiving and leaving in my humidor. What an excellent treat!'t wait to age a few. I can I started out as a Cuban smoker and have found the standard among non-Cubans that I can buy in the States. The dark wrapper makes you think that it will be bold but it is medium bodied. The flavors are excellent with a creamy chocolate that changes to spicy and then back to creamy chocolate again. It took a good 90-100 minutes to smoke due to its size. Draw was good with an excellent white ash that stayed a while. An excellent choice for mild-medium bodied lovers. I will be getting a large number more of these!!! An Excellent Value!

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (8) No (12)

"Not bad"

Review by: Anderson
Review Date: 08/21/2009
Rating: 5.8
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: Very smooth and no bitter taste. Went great with a Corona beer.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (10) No (10)


Page 2 of 17 :: PREVIOUS PAGE | NEXT PAGE
Go To Page: [ 1 ][ 2 ][ 3 ][ 4 ][ 5 ][ 6 ][ 7 ][ 8 ][ 9 ][ 10 ][ 11 ][ 12 ][ 13 ][ 14 ][ 15 ][ 16 ][ 17 ]

Quick Rating
100% of voters like the Excalibur by HDM - No. I (M)
Vote Now! This cigar SMOKES! (14) This cigar is a DUD. (0)



Add A Review Of This Cigar
Just fill out the form below to create a rating and review of this cigar. Once you submit your review you cannot change it.
Please check your spelling and information before clicking the "Submit Your Review" button.


Reviewer Name


WARNING - YOU ARE NOT LOGGED IN!

If you wish for this review to be credited to your account name and viewable in the 'Reviews by user' report, then you must have an account with Puff.com and be logged in while submitting the review. To create an account, Click Here. To LOG IN, use the login form on the right.


Review Title
(A couple word summary of your review...)
Review Comments
Price Paid $ (Approx. price paid per cigar.)
Appearance  (1 to 10)
Construction  (1 to 10)          10 = Perfect Smoke
Flavor  (1 to 10)          5 = About Average
Value  (1 to 10)          1 = Not Worth It
Overall Smoking Experience  (1 to 10)
Spam Protection
   Image Text:

      



   

Latest Cigar Video

Sign Up to our
GET IT NOW!






 

Member Cigar Reviews | Staff Cigar Reviews | Cigar Videos | One on One Interviews | Cigar News | Puffcast | Cigar Forums | Lifestyle | Partners | Contact
© 2015 by Caputo Media, LLC. All rights reserved. Cluster hosted by Hostway.
Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ad Blockers Suck! Why?


Puff.com Daily Digest

Thank you for your interest in the Puff.com Daily Digest. Get notified of all new content on Puff.com in our free Daily Digest. To subscribe, enter your email address below and click the subscribe button.


Email Address:


Email will come from "donotreply@caputomedia.com". Please whitelist this email address.

Cancel and Return to page