MEMBER CIGAR REVIEWS | STAFF CIGAR REVIEWS | CIGAR VIDEOS | ONE ON ONE INTERVIEWS | CIGAR NEWS | CIGAR FORUMS | PIPES | LIFESTYLE | CONTACT
 
Excalibur by HDM No. I (M) Cigar Reviews
Below are the cigar reviews for the Excalibur by HDM No. I (M). If you would like to add your own personal cigar review for the Excalibur by HDM No. I (M) please click here.


Cigar Vitals


Excalibur by HDM Cigars
  No. I (M)       

Current Rating
8.63

Size: NA
Shape: Double Corona
Wrapper: NA
Filler: NA
Binder: NA
MSRP: 5.75
Total Reviews: 81
Average Rating: 8.63 out of a possible 10
Average Price: 5.32
Discontinued: No
Notes:

Quick Rating
100% of voters like the Excalibur by HDM - No. I (M)
Vote Now! This cigar SMOKES! (14) This cigar is a DUD. (0)

Page 3 of 17 :: PREVIOUS PAGE | NEXT PAGE

"Great Giant"

Review by: JeffinChi
Review Date: 06/08/2009
Rating: 8.2
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: Been smoking these for a couple years now. Nice slow burn especially for it's size, good draw. Smooth and mellow with a sweet taste, maybe a little bit of java. These are good right out of the box, or aged in the humi. A solid choice.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (5) No (4)

"First Review"

Review by: SigSauerRRA
Review Date: 02/28/2009
Rating: 10
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: This is my first review, so take it as you will. I smoke cigars often and decided to save money and buy a box. Based on puff.com reviews, I chose this cigar... The construction and appearance were better than any I've had. (Disclaimer: I don't believe in exotic flavors people claim in many reviews. I'm either not "refined" enough to taste them or they're all full of s***. To me, there are good cigars and there are bad cigars.) This cigar was very good. If forced to pick a taste, I would say a mellow sweet, peppery flavor came out at times. There were absolutely no charred or bitter tastes, even when lighting up. It burned perfectly with a nice snowy ash and produced ample smoke. I don't know if it was good company, the whiskey, or the cigar but this is the best I've had. I plan to buy another box. That is all. No bull s*** here.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (5) No (8)

"A classic"

Review by: smoke stack
Review Date: 06/11/2008
Rating: 7.83
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: A solid smoke in every sense. This stick does not excel in any one category, it does well in all of them. I take this stick out every time I want to insure I have a good smoke. It never falls short.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (6) No (3)

"Excellent"

Review by: alchemyhunter
Review Date: 05/28/2008
Rating: 8.67
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: This was an excellent cigar. I bought a box for my daughters birth. Truly excellent.... excellent wrapper and appearance. Great flavor with an even burn. I will make sure that my humidor is never out of them again.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (9) No (11)

"Well crafted but dull"

Review by: kevink868
Review Date: 10/30/2007
Rating: 6.67
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Appearance
Construction
Flavor
Value
Overall Experience

Review Notes: Good looking wrapper. First third tastes like, well, CTBL. In a good way, since I've always loved the broadleaf. But there wasn't much going on beneath the sweet and peppery zing of the wrapper. Given the size of this behemoth, I kept waiting for the flavors to evolve, but to no avail. There was a little woody base, but it was relatively static for 90 minutes. For someone seeking their CTBL fix, there are cheaper, less cumbersome ways to get it.

Does this reviewer know this cigar? Yes (7) No (6)


Page 3 of 17 :: PREVIOUS PAGE | NEXT PAGE
Go To Page: [ 1 ][ 2 ][ 3 ][ 4 ][ 5 ][ 6 ][ 7 ][ 8 ][ 9 ][ 10 ][ 11 ][ 12 ][ 13 ][ 14 ][ 15 ][ 16 ][ 17 ]

Quick Rating
100% of voters like the Excalibur by HDM - No. I (M)
Vote Now! This cigar SMOKES! (14) This cigar is a DUD. (0)



Add A Review Of This Cigar
Just fill out the form below to create a rating and review of this cigar. Once you submit your review you cannot change it.
Please check your spelling and information before clicking the "Submit Your Review" button.


Reviewer Name


WARNING - YOU ARE NOT LOGGED IN!

If you wish for this review to be credited to your account name and viewable in the 'Reviews by user' report, then you must have an account with Puff.com and be logged in while submitting the review. To create an account, Click Here. To LOG IN, use the login form on the right.


Review Title
(A couple word summary of your review...)
Review Comments
Price Paid $ (Approx. price paid per cigar.)
Appearance  (1 to 10)
Construction  (1 to 10)          10 = Perfect Smoke
Flavor  (1 to 10)          5 = About Average
Value  (1 to 10)          1 = Not Worth It
Overall Smoking Experience  (1 to 10)
Spam Protection
   Image Text:

      



   


Sign Up to our
GET IT NOW!






 

Member Cigar Reviews | Staff Cigar Reviews | Cigar Videos | One on One Interviews | Cigar News | Puffcast | Cigar Forums | Lifestyle | Partners | Contact
© 2015 by Caputo Media, LLC. All rights reserved.
Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ad Blockers Suck! Why?


Puff.com Daily Digest

Thank you for your interest in the Puff.com Daily Digest. Get notified of all new content on Puff.com in our free Daily Digest. To subscribe, enter your email address below and click the subscribe button.


Email Address:


Email will come from "donotreply@caputomedia.com". Please whitelist this email address.

Cancel and Return to page