Review Notes: I have smoke dozens of these in the past, but not lately until last night. The construction was a Perfect 10, flavor was medium with a nice finish, value--it was a freebie that was in the humidor for a couple years, just wonderful!

Review Notes: Everything you want a cigar to be; burn, flavor, construction...it's all there. I get a box every year and they keep living up to my expectations.

Review Notes: given to me as a b-day gift last month and i am now hooked. loads of deep flavors and an even burn. worth vacationing in cuba just to get my hands on these again.

Review Notes: My wife and I had Glenn and his lovely wife Kim over for a steak dinner Friday night. After dinner, over Ginger Brandys, in front of the patio fire, we smoked our "Montys". They were both exceptional (unless Glenn was just being polite). I kept saying during the 2 hour experience, "this is why we smoke cigars". Burn, draw, flavors, were all top notch. The flavors to me were that of a Snickers candy bar. These 2 had been in the box for at least 3 years (sci ron is right on regarding aging). Overall, when these are "on" they are fantastic. The trouble with these is that they are not always "on". Good luck with yours. I'll enter 16.50 for pp$.

Review Notes: I have been smoking these babies for many a year and have found the REAL McCoys are pretty consistent. Also note that I keep them in my humidor for at least 1 year before they are lit. The longer they sit in a controlled atmosphere the better they get. I remember my first box of these beauties. Couldn't wait to get the box opened. Well they were green and so was I they tasted terrible couldn't keep them lit etc. Was ready to give them away when a friend suggested letting them age for 6 months WOW what a difference!!! So for those having a bad experience you most likley have cigars that need aging or you just don't have the real McCoy