Review Notes: This cigar is a good cheap cigar, but I do not understand how this cigar can get rated above a Montecristo No. 2(Cuba) or a Cuaba Salomones. If a Montecristo No. 2 (Cuba) is an 8.8 than this is closer to a six. Good smoke, but burns a little hot, a tinge of metallic flavour, and ends up being a tad harsh.

Review Notes: I get these also for 3.45 each in singles, and have yet to have a bad one. For the price one of the best medium-bodied smokes, and I haven't found a better one in this format yet. Most of them have a slight sharpness at light, but all immediately turn earthy, sweetish and smooth. The flavor slowly turns toasty, slightly spicy and grassy, with cedary overtones and a smooth burn to the fingertips. The Punch MM Rothschild is easily the best medium-bodied smoke I have tried.

Review Notes: I buy this one in singles for $3.45 and have yet to find a better quality cigar for the price. Consistently smooth with only occasionally irregular burn. Excellent toasty, earthy, sweetish flavor that burns to the fingers without bite. Never a "stinky stogie." Medium to full-bodied, emphasis on medium.

Review Notes: this is a must have for me. a box a year. after a year in the humidor this is as good as just about any cigar. smooth, never a problem with the roll. big mouthfuls of smoke. very nice.

Review Notes: Very nice smoke. Always looking for a value and this did not disappoint one bit. Nice even burn, unlike some others in this line. Great flavor and draw. Overall just a very satisfying smoke. This will be one of my staples.