Review Notes: This is a solid cigar with no major weakness or significant flaws. The flavor is above average with pepper, some cedar and sweetness and a hint of cream. It does lack the complexity of a first tier smoke (IMHO). This lack of complexity is typical for the CAO Black line. The Gothic is a handsome cigar that had an excellent burn and draw. The price is not too bad if you shop around. Overall, a very agreeable stick.