[MikeZ]

Complete conjecture on my part here...but could it be possible that if the cigars are returned to the manufacturer then the royalty doesn't have to be paid to HBO? If the cigars are discounted and sold, royalties could be due.

Of course this depends on the definition of a "sold" cigar in the deal that CAO and HBO have...or even if sales volume come into play at all. Like I said, I have no idea but it's just one slim possibility as to why a cigar might be recalled instead of blown out.