Who do you trust?

[gehrig97]

Wondering: Where does everybody go for cigar reviews they can trust? (Let's just assume Top 25 Cigars.com makes the list... where else do you go for good info?)

[TripleF]

Don't know of a more comprehensive list.......anywhere.

That's my

[taltos]

I would see if there was a review posted here or on Herfer's Paradise. If I knew the reviewer and his tastes, it would be easy to see what review to trust.

[glking]

I get the best information here!

[hoosier]

Originally Posted by fishforfree

Don't know of a more comprehensive list.......anywhere.

That's my

I'm with fishforfree. I also read the following reviews on a regular basis:
http://cigarfan.wordpress.com/
http://www.stogieguys.com/
http://www.cigarcyclopedia.com/webap...t/view/972/90/
And of course the reviews on ClubStogie!!!
Hope this helps.

[sanfrantreat]

I go to Porrigity or Bear.. lol

[zemekone]

just here, i grab a single and if i like it i like it, if i dont then i dont...

[ca21455]

Take a look at my post: http://www.clubstogie.com/vb/showthread.php?t=126373

Most reviews have some value to them. Take a look around and find something or someone that agrees with your taste.

For the most part I always try them out for myself. Tastes vary a lot but when many reviews trash a smoke you can be pretty sure it is a bum cigar.

Happy hunting, that is 80% of the cigar experience!

[Rahllin]

If I really want to review a cigar before I buy it... I'll check out as many reviews as I can find... that way I can make my own conclusion based off several people's experiences, keeping them all in mind.

[guy g]

I too get most of my info here because there are usually several opinions to a paricular smoke. After that , I taste for myself.

[Da Klugs]

Trust your sense of taste.

Do trades/PIF's here to try things or buy singles/samplers from the various vendors.

Or

Buy boxes of every cigar made in every brand. Smoke all of them and see which one's you prefer.

[BamBam]

Originally Posted by gehrig97

Wondering: Where does everybody go for cigar reviews they can trust? (Let's just assume Top 25 Cigars.com makes the list... where else do you go for good info?)

Top25 is always my first stop when curious about a stick.
But I also enjoy going to The Stogie Guys at www.stogieguys.com and The Stogie Review www.************.com. Both of these sites have a large list of cigars with a good detailed review.

[Patbo]

If I am in a cigar shop, I ask my wife to find it. She has a nose for the cigars that I would like unlike any other. Otherwise, I ask my friends, they know more than I do.

When I was younger and traveled out of the country, I relied on Cigar Aficionado ratings on Cubans of that year. But the problem there is the spotty quality control and lack of consistency.

Usually, I smoke it and if I like it, I buy more.

Patrick

[SilverFox]

I have to say that I have gone through CA with a fine tooth comb but I prefer to get the opinions of gorrillas here.

Mostly because they don't try to impress with unnecessary comparisons to 7 year old Madagascar Vanilla.

[Ratters]

I learned a lot from Walt and ************.com and can trust his opinions cause I feel we have similar tastes. But what's a great cigar to one tastes like crap to another, so you just gotta try some different things and go from there.