Moral Dilemma

[Poriggity]

Call em and send them back.

[SmokeyJoe]

Originally Posted by ShaulWolf

I'd call them up and send them back. It's just the right thing to do...

You never have a problem sleeping with a clear conscience. My .

[tzaddi]

If one believes we are all brothers & sisters (of the leaf) as we profess then there is only one answer.

[redryno247]

Originally Posted by tzaddi

If one believes we are all brothers & sisters (of the leaf) as we profess then there is only one answer.

Amen....send them back, do the right thing and poof, dilemma resolved.

[gnukfu]

I think most folks here aren't going to take advantage of a mistake.

Crying out loud we're all trying to give our cigars away to each other! We don't want the blooming things anyway! Speaking of that i'm smoking the San Cristobal you sent me Darrell - man is this good!!!

[Pat1075]

call the and tell them they made an error, then send them back

[Opusfxd]

Karma is king. I'd send em back.

[andrewsutherland2002]

Legaly they are yours. If the company ships them to you after you have puchased something, regardless if what you recieved is what you purchased, it belongs to you. Morally, it still belongs to CI. I would probably keep them though, but I'm a sorry SOB.
then again, CI has been good to me, so I should return the favor to them.

[dwhitacre]

[SIZE="4"]You have waited long enough![/SIZE]

[SIZE="3"]Of course[/SIZE] she called CI immediately and they are sending the postage for her to send them back!!!

But we had to take a picture of the CI Bomb before we sent them back

[RUJohnny99]

I'd hate the thought of some poor bastid in the warehouse getting canned over a couple boxes of freaking Backwoods.

[smokin5]

Good for you! That's the BOTL/SOTL way.
Karma WILL repay you double.

Of course, as we say around here,
"No Good Deed Goes Unpunished".

[Jbailey]

Originally Posted by dwhitacre

Looks like photoshop gone bad.

[ResIpsa]

Originally Posted by andrewsutherland2002

Legaly they are yours. If the company ships them to you after you have puchased something, regardless if what you recieved is what you purchased, it belongs to you. Morally, it still belongs to CI. I would probably keep them though, but I'm a sorry SOB.
then again, CI has been good to me, so I should return the favor to them.

Really?

I believe the OP lives in California.

I don't mean for this to sound harsh, and I don't mean to sound "uppity" but I have to say that more and more lately I'm seeing posts where people are referring to the legality of various things, and giving legal opinions as to them.

Unless a member here is a practicing attorney in the OP's state, I would refrain from commenting on the "legality" of this particular situation, or any situation in general. You may give someone very bad "legal" advice that costs them a jail term, a hefty fine or hefty legal fees.

On point, I can tell you that in New York if someone mistakenly ships you merchandise you are NOT the legal owner, and DO NOT have the right to keep it, although Business Law is not my area of expertise, and please, no one should take that as legal advice

[taltos]

Vic, I think that the poster was confusing this type of situation with unsolicited gifts such as fund raining mailings. Just my from what I remember about business law in grad school.

[ResIpsa]

Originally Posted by taltos

Vic, I think that the poster was confusing this type of situation with unsolicited gifts such as fund raining mailings. Just my from what I remember about business law in grad school.

Sounds like a reasonable explanation to me Paul.