CSI: Club Stogie 2- Six Smokes, Six brands, Three fakes...

[Stogiefanatic182]

H Upmann- Band of off center and print is fuzzy
Boli- Inner circle is crooked, no triple cap
RJ- inner band is to high up against the white backround of the outer band, no triple cap, gold doesnt seem as shiney as on a real one

[CrazyFool]

4 pages now, wow! still there is one combination of 3 cigars that has not been mentioned yet... it may be the only combination of 3 brands that hasnt been mentioned yet- and its the correct one!!! i didnt think this would last this long OMG!!

good luck and chin up for one more go!

[SeanGAR]

Upmann, Punch (bad wrappers), Cohiba (cap, band).

[illuminatus]

ERDM - No Triple Cap
Punch - Band is offset (no box press?)
Boli - Habana is wrong, tunic is wrong

This SHOULD be right..

[illuminatus]

Sorry, didn't want to edit the last post and look like I'm cheating.. what meant was:

ERDM - No triple cap
RyJ - No triple cap, band is offcenter
Punch - Band offcenter (no box press?)

[Stogiefanatic182]

ERDM- Crappy construction, no triple cap
RJ- Red part of the band is off center
Punch- Letters are wrong font, band is offcenter, and no triple cap

[Andyman]

Originally Posted by illuminatus

Sorry, didn't want to edit the last post and look like I'm cheating.. what meant was

Are you trying to say something to me?? just come out and say it then...

[illuminatus]

Originally Posted by Andyman

Are you trying to say something to me?? just come out and say it then...

Wouldn't dream of it.. I didn't even notice you'd edited any of your posts. I just didn't want anyone coming in and saying "He edited it! He cheated!" So I made a new post. I'm 99.999999999% sure I got the 'gars right, if not 100% positive on the reasons. Assuming the Cohiba is REAL, but the old style band,I made a chart of every possible combination of 3 of the 5 remaing 'gars. I then compared it to what had already been posted. I came up with exactly one combination that had not been posted. I may have done it wrong.. we shall see.

[Andyman]

I tried this on paper this afternoon while trying to talk on the phone to clients.. It did not work so well. Wish I would have had more time.. But yes I edited the post when I changed my mind.. The last post I edited 5 or 6 times to get the quotes right.. I accept failure..

[illuminatus]

Originally Posted by Andyman

I tried this on paper this afternoon while trying to talk on the phone to clients.. It did not work so well. Wish I would have had more time.. But yes I edited the post when I changed my mind.. The last post I edited 5 or 6 times to get the quotes right.. I accept failure..

I just sat here with headphones and tried to drown out my annoying ass roommate chewing ice.. I want to bash his head in! Ok.. back on topic.. Like I said.. I made a chart, and I'm 99.999999999% sure these are correct... so now we just need Crazyfool to step in and confirm it...

[Andyman]

Can we make the next one scartch and sniff?

[Stogiefanatic182]

Originally Posted by Andyman

Can we make the next one scartch and sniff?

I say the next one should have nick banned from the contest because he seems to be way to good at these. Just kidding Nick, you have a gift what can I say.

[Andyman]

Originally Posted by Andyman

Can we make the next one scartch and sniff?

This goes for the next blonde bombshell contest too..

[illuminatus]

Originally Posted by Stogiefanatic182

I say the next one should have nick banned from the contest because he seems to be way to good at these. Just kidding Nick, you have a gift what can I say.

HEY! We're not even sure I won this one yet! Based on the fact that crazyfool hasn't posted yet, I'm kinda wondering if I did! Besides, you came up with the same answer I did... just TOO LATE! So we shall see.... and if I win.. well.. what can I say, I'm just that good!

[Gordie]

I'll guess RyJ (printing on ref bad doesn't look as good as most current smokes).
H. Upmann (Color is wrong, band looks bad)
Cohiba (La Habana looks too thick/black)