Graycliffs: Are they all this good?

[GolfNut]

OK, I lit up my first Graycliff the other night. It was the 1666 I received from a big CI Sampler (5 of them!) This thing was SO good! Creamy smoke and wonderful flavors. I couldn't get enough of it!

Are all the Graycliffs this good? I have a Crystal in the Humi my wife got me for my Birthday. I've been reluctant to try it since I only have the one. Now I'm even more reluctant, because if it's even better than the 1666. I KNOW I'm going to want more of them and DANG they're spendy cigars!

[poriggity-cl]

I've only had a couple graycliffs, because they aren't really in my budget, but I hear those 1666's are good.
Scott

[baboruger]

The Crystal is ok if you don't expect a really Full Bodied stick. here are some reviews from the IL boys...

http://www.cigarlive.com/forum/t1910...al-pirate.html

[Snapperhead-cl]

I have had a couple...I can honestly say that I have not found one that I did not like yet.

[iloveclmore]

I've had one, but it wasn't all that good, at least not for the price.

[baboruger]

Originally Posted by triplezero24

I've had one, but it wasn't all that good, at least not for the price.

you'll have two when you do the review! I hope you like that one...

[DOZER]

I've had the reds and the blues and didn't care for them. The 1666 I had was quite good but still not worth the price to me. I've heard good things about the double espresso and want to try one but at $18 a stick I cant justify pulling the trigger.

[baboruger]

Originally Posted by DOZER

I've had the reds and the blues and didn't care for them. The 1666 I had was quite good but still not worth the price to me. I've heard good things about the double espresso and want to try one but at $18 a stick I cant justify pulling the trigger.

The double espresso is not $18 a stick on Cbid...more in the range of $6-$7

[tobacmon]

I actually enjoy the Graycliff Crystal Pirate myself-Torpedo Shape--Did not feel it was as full as it should have been but really thought was a very complexed smoke with lots of flavors and smoke. My 2C.

[baboruger]

Originally Posted by tobacmon

I actually enjoy the Graycliff Crystal Pirate myself-Torpedo Shape--Did not feel it was as full as it should have been but really thought was a very complexed smoke with lots of flavors and smoke. My 2C.

I sent you one of those right?

[Paint]

I like them all,some are better than others,like the espresso &double espresso are my favorite,They seem to be more full flavored to me.

[LkyLindy]

they were ok-but don't make it to my "hit" list

[tobacmon]

Originally Posted by baboruger

I sent you one of those right?

Not sure --I did do a trade with Giacomo though --- Sorry if I don't rem,ember about the one you sent--Was I suppose to do a review? I've been so dang busy it being cruise season and all--let me know - PM me!

[Jonjonmacky]

Ive had only one, the presidente blue band or something or other. and it was truly a creamy creamy smoke, that was one thing that really stood out to me, it was hard to keep lit sometimes, but it pulled through, Im glad i paid 12 dollars instead of 22, cause I think 12 is a solid price for that cigar. Though a little mild for my tastes I really loved it. very relaxing.

[Wideboy]

I agree they are a good smoke, but I can't see buying them at MSRP. Most of the ones I have smoked have been gifts or in samplers. Occasionally I think hmmmm Maybe I should consider a box, but the price is just too much to justify.