The above video goes away if you are a member and logged in, so log in now!
 

CIGAR REVIEWS | CIGAR VIDEOS | INTERVIEWS | CIGAR NEWS | OUR TWO CENTS BLOGS | PUFFCAST | CIGAR FORUMS | PUFF LIFESTYLE | CONTACT

Puff Cigar Discussion Forums

Go Back   Puff Cigar Discussion Forums > The Cigar Lounges at Puff > General Cigar Discussion

What's your rating system?

This is a discussion on What's your rating system? within the General Cigar Discussion forums, part of the The Cigar Lounges at Puff category; I have a cigar rating .xls spreadsheet that I log for my cigars on a 1-10 scale... Not that I ...

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 07-16-2009, 05:13 AM   #31
Puffer Fish with some spikes
 
defcon3's Avatar

defcon3's Profile
Join Date: May 2009
City: Fort Lauderdale
State: Florida
Just Smoked: Oliva V!!!
Posts: 236
Gameroom cash: $1251
Ring Gauge: 26
defcon3's Icons
 
Re: What's your rating system?

I have a cigar rating .xls spreadsheet that I log for my cigars on a 1-10 scale...

Not that I have a bad memory (there are cigars I know NEVER to buy again) but in trying alot of various smokes, samplers, etc. I can reflect on it to see what I may want to buy a box of or try again...

There are exceptions... After smoking an Olivia V, there was no alternative, simply bought a box...
defcon3 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-16-2009, 12:22 PM   #32
Leading Puffer Fish
 
nativetexan_1's Avatar

nativetexan_1's Profile
Join Date: Dec 2007
City: Canton
State: Texas
Real First Name: Jerry
Posts: 1,004
Gameroom cash: $4027
Ring Gauge: 109
nativetexan_1's Icons
 
Re: What's your rating system?

I try to keep it (what seems to me to be) simple:

Appearance: 0-1 1) I like the looks of it, 0) I probably didn't buy it to begin with
Draw: 0-2 0) somewhat like drawing air through a straw or a rock, 1) a little snug, 2) just right
Burn: 0-2 0) I have to straighten or relight more than twice, 1) maybe only once, 2) burns right by itself
Construction: 0-1 0) wrapper comes loose, lots of loose tobacco, or breaks off too soon on it's own, 1) everything stays together (actually, a lot of construction is assumed to take place in the apperance, draw, and burn categories above)
Flavor: 0-3 0) I either had to choke it down or I threw it away about half-way cause I couldn't stand it, 1) distasteful, but bearable, 2) pleasant, 3) makes me want another
Overall: 0-1 0) never again, 1) it was worth the money.

Total: 0-10, <7) probable won't spend the money on them again, 7+) worth another try UNLESS OVERALL IS 0, in which case, "never again".
__________________
Canton, Texas: home of First Monday Trades Day.
nativetexan_1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-17-2009, 12:31 AM   #33
Alpha Puffer Fish
 
baba's Avatar

baba's Profile
Join Date: Nov 2007
City: seattle -
Posts: 1,596
Gameroom cash: $2087
Ring Gauge: 27
baba's Icons
 
Re: What's your rating system?

Mine is very easy. A B C D F - just like school it can be outstanding - very good - good - or average - or nasty.
baba is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Tags
rating , system

Go Back   Puff Cigar Discussion Forums > The Cigar Lounges at Puff > General Cigar Discussion

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On





All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:17 AM.


© 2009 by Puff Enterprises. All rights reserved. Puff Cluster hosted by Hostway.
Terms of Service - Privacy Policy