I have a few Anejo's in my humi. I smoked one a couple of weeks back at a wedding. Best cigar I have had to date. Of course, that is my opinion. Try to get one while you are saving up. If you like it, keep on saving. If you don't, then you know to spend your cash elsewhere.
As for which one, everyone seems to like the #77 Shark. No idea what MSRP is on a box or if you can get it for that.