Here is my reasoning for being more towards the hate camp.
I couldnt keep the stuff lit. I dried it out for varying times. I packed it different ways. I just didnt have much luck. This then forced me to puff like a demon. The result is a hot burning nic kick to the nutz and a washed out flavor. Whenever I tried to slow it down I spent all of my time relighting. To much maintenance for me and I could never get to any flavor.
Seems like I read somewhere that Orlik has issues with QC. Maybe I got a bad tin. My other tin is in the cellar and I am afraid to crack it.