Top 10 Running Backs Ever!

[justinphilly]

again, more debates

Jim Brown
Walter Payton
Barry Sanders
Tony Dorsett
Erik Dickerson
Gale Sayers
Marshall Faulk
Emmitt Smith
Marcus Allen
Earl Campbell

again, who would you add/remove?

let me explain why i am doing this.. i work at a sports bar, and this debate comes up ALL the time! (see also the quarteback thread) But what i want to do is get more opinions to see where we stand)

[Ermo]

It depends on if you're looking at "pure stats", "the best runner", or "the one running back you'd want on your team".

Pure stats its easy to make the list, but I wouldn't want Barry Sanders' quitter a$$ on my team, little sissy that quits when things don't go his way then hides from everyone.

[booboo]

I would want Sanders on my team for sure. He was a one of a kind. And great to watch

[Ermo]

Originally Posted by booboo

I would want Sanders on my team for sure. He was a one of a kind. And great to watch

Hope you guys win or he'll just bail on you. I'd take Dickerson, Payton, or Brown over Sanders any day of the week.

[Nerachnia]

OJ has to be on this list

[booboo]

I was thinking about that. Sanders did everything he did with no one else on his team. I am not saying the other guys on the list is bad because there is not a bad RB on that list. For sanders things were bad for a long time.

[Ermo]

Originally Posted by Nerachnia

OJ has to be on this list

Again are we talking pure stats or a guy you want on your team? I dont want OJ on my team but he put up good numbers.

[booboo]

Originally Posted by Ermo

Again are we talking pure stats or a guy you want on your team? I dont want OJ on my team but he put up good numbers.

All right on stats who is your top guy?

on who do you want on your team top guy?

[Ermo]

Originally Posted by booboo

All right on stats who is your top guy?

on who do you want on your team top guy?

Stats I'd want Barry.

On my actual team I'd want Walter Payton.

[SilvrBck]

I know I'm biased but how do you think L. Tomlinson is going to fit in this list?

[justinphilly]

DOES ANOYNE KNOW HOW TO FOLLOW INSTRUCTIONS???

i need people's top 10's!!!!

please!

[booboo]

Originally Posted by justinphilly

DOES ANOYNE KNOW HOW TO FOLLOW INSTRUCTIONS???

i need people's top 10's!!!!

please!

Payton
Brown
Sanders
Sayers
Dickerson
Dorsett
Allen
E Smith
Simpson
Cambell

How is that for Following rules lol

[justinphilly]

Originally Posted by booboo

Payton
Brown
Sanders
Sayers
Dickerson
Dorsett
Allen
E Smith
Simpson
Cambell

How is that for Following rules lol

thank you!!!

[chuckojr]

The only thing that I would change about the list would be to take Marcus Allen out and put in "the Juice". Personal opinions aside, the man could run.

[ky toker]

Jim Thorpe
Barry Sanders
Earl Campbell
Larry Csonka
Jim Brown
Eric Dickerson
Jim Taylor
Walter Payton
Franco Harris
Tony Dorsett