The Man Cave
Lower Level
10541 Main Street
Hayward, WI 54843
www[dot]themancavestore[dot]com (I can't post links yet, sorry.)

Pretty good selection of cigars. Good mix of premiums and everyday smokes. A few Padrons, CAO, Rocky Patel, Fuente, Oliva, and the like. Prices aren't great, but a better shop in Northern Wisconsin you will not find. Great selection of accessories too. Humidors, travel cases, cutters, lighters, and lots of Xikar accessories.